What it is: A bestselling luxury eye pencil that glides on ultra-creamy and delivers long-lasting eyeliner looks that won’t smudge—now in viral shade, Space Cowboy.
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. It is also vegan, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.
What Else You Need to Know: The Space Cowboy eyeliner gives you a warm shimmery nude liner in the same 24/7 formula—so you get a smooth application without dragging or pulling. Once dry, this eyeliner pencil is waterproof and smudge-proof for up to 16 hours of wear. Try it and see why it’s the number-one luxury eye pencil.
This used to be my long time go-to but the quality is terrible now. Unable to sharpen without breaking. Doesn’t go on smoothly. I now use NYX - cheaper and a better product
Read more
Mommalew
Blue eyes, Medium Tan skin tone, Normal skin
1w ago
Definitely something wrong w this formulation. Doesn’t apply well. Smudges super easily. Doesn’t stay on. Useless. Saw an influencer use this color for brown eyes and got it. :(
Read more
krza
Brown eyes, Fair skin tone, Oily skin
Verified Purchase
2w ago
Need to find a new favorite
I’m sad to write this review because this has been my favorite eyeliner for over 15 years. I adore the bourbon shade. Something has changed with the formula and it’s barely even usable at this point. It doesn’t go on as smoothly or as pigmented as it used to and when I try to sharpen it, the tip just keeps breaking off. The last time I tried to sharpen it the back of the pencil cracked off. How does that even happen? I even repurchased the pencil from another retailer just to see if it was a fluke, but the same thing happened.
Read more
sansevieria415
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
2w ago
Broken and haven’t even properly used it
The tip snapped off as soon as I got home and opened it. I barely even touched it and boom, the tip was gone.
Read more
NadineKent
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone
3w ago
This is not a stay all day eyeliner on the waterline. It doesn’t run but it absolutely wears off and gathers in the corners of my eyes.
Read more
HannahRie
Brown eyes, Fair skin tone, Combination skin
3w ago
Not the same
These used to be so good. I don’t know what happened. They must have changed the formula, but now these barely stay on, go on terribly, and break easily. So disappointed!
Read more
oliviaop
Light Medium skin tone, Normal skin
3w ago
Don’t buy Better options are out there
This product is good however I thought this would be able to go on my waterline but it wasn’t able to. The liner go everywhere on the packaging and is difficult to sharpen. Nice try but save your money
Read more
beautyqueenluvr
4w ago
Nice colors, but wouldn’t repurchase
I have the black and the brown. The colors are nice and the application was smooth at first. And maybe because I don’t use it often and it has gotten old, it doesn’t apply as well. When I sharpen it, it has broken. Sometimes when I take the cap off, the color part comes out of the pencil and I have to push it back in. There’s just so many other products out there to try so I probably won’t re-purchase. 
Read more
alexisnt
Green eyes, Medium skin tone, Combination skin
1mo ago
Recommended
Nice eyeliner
[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] This is a nice eyeliner pencil. The shade is great and it has some build ability. The wear time could have been better for me and I had some transfer to under my eye.
Read more
lulu22455
Green eyes, Light skin tone, Combination skin
Incentivized
Verified Purchase
1mo ago
Don’t purchase
There is nothing about this pencil that glides. I have tried multiple angles and it looks like cheap, wet and wild eyeliner from the drugstore. I also tried the tarte and it was terrible.
Read more
zilalah
Green eyes, Fair skin tone, Combination skin
What it is: A bestselling luxury eye pencil that glides on ultra-creamy and delivers long-lasting eyeliner looks that won’t smudge—now in viral shade, Space Cowboy.
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. It is also vegan, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.
What Else You Need to Know: The Space Cowboy eyeliner gives you a warm shimmery nude liner in the same 24/7 formula—so you get a smooth application without dragging or pulling. Once dry, this eyeliner pencil is waterproof and smudge-proof for up to 16 hours of wear. Try it and see why it’s the number-one luxury eye pencil.
Suggested Usage: -For precise lines: Use the eye pencil to draw precise lines. -For smokey eyes: Smudge out your pencil to create a classic smokey eye look. -Use as a shadow: The creaminess of this formula allows for easy blending to create the perfect eyeshadow look. -Use as an eyeshadow base: For added depth and dimension, use Space Cowboy eyeliner as a base under your eyeshadow. -Transform your eye look: Buildable formula can take you from day to night. -Keep sharp: For easy use and the sharpest wing, keep your eyeliner ready with an eyeliner pencil sharpener (sold separately).
Summary
5
4
3
2
1
4.4★
18909 Reviews*
80%
Recommended
*Some reviewers received something in exchange for a review (free product, payment, sweeps entry).
